Opposition politician and lawyer, Fadzayi Mahere, has reduced her claim for damages from $1 million to $50,000 in her ongoing legal battle with author, Petina Gappah.
Despite Gappah’s recent apology and retraction of her statements, Mahere is proceeding with the case, alleging that the apology is insincere and that Gappah continues to make defamatory statements.
Mahere’s lawsuit against Gappah stems from allegations made by Gappah about Mahere’s university placements and personal relationships. Gappah had accused Mahere of securing university placements through her father’s influence, and also alleged that Mahere tried to seduce the father of her child. Mahere has denied these allegations, stating that they are defamatory and have caused harm to her reputation.
In her submissions before Justice Jacob Mafusire, Mahere asserted that Gappah’s apology and retraction were insincere and that Gappah has persisted with the defamatory allegations.
Mahere accused Gappah of using the court to damage her reputation and that of her family. “This is a continuation of a pattern of defamation against myself, my father, and my family,” said Mahere. She added that Gappah’s actions demonstrate a propensity to continue making defamatory statements despite the apology.
Gappah countered, saying it was Mahere who introduced her father to the case, making it fair for her to address related questions. She also alleged that Mahere’s colleague, David Coltart, had made similar allegations against Mahere’s father.
READ ALSO: Nigeria’s NCDC Unveils Ambitious Plan to Boost Public Health Infrastructure
However, Mahere’s lawyer objected, arguing that this was irrelevant to the proceedings. Gappah insisted that her statements did not harm Mahere’s career or activism, citing Mahere’s subsequent appointments and opportunities. She argued that her widely circulated apology and retraction should mitigate any harm caused.
The matter has been adjourned indefinitely, with both parties scheduled to file their closing submissions in June and July.
Gappah is set to file her submissions on June 17, while Mahere, represented by Nokhuthula Moyo, will file hers on July 2, 2024. The case has sparked interest in the legal and political circles, with many watching to see how it will unfold.
